It is currently Wed Nov 18, 2026 6:09 am


All times are UTC - 5 hours [ DST ]



Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 70 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next

Create A Section For Focused Critique?
Yes, Create A Section For Focused Critique (disallow critique in the Art section) 12%  12%  [ 4 ]
Yes, Create A Section For Focused Critique (continue to allow critique in the Art section) 32%  32%  [ 11 ]
No, Things Are Fine The Way They Are 53%  53%  [ 18 ]
I Hate Polls 3%  3%  [ 1 ]
Total votes : 34
Author Message
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Mon Aug 19, 2013 3:28 pm  (#41) 
Offline
GimpChat Member
User avatar

Joined: Nov 09, 2011
Posts: 726
Good idea Mokonafan.
I prefer "Critique welcomed" or "This thread is Focused for Critique", instead of "No Critique wanted".
"No Critique wanted" in some way also be conditioning about what a user can write.

_________________
Image
Be patient, English is not my language.


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Mon Aug 19, 2013 3:35 pm  (#42) 
Offline
GimpChat Member
User avatar

Joined: Apr 08, 2010
Posts: 5420
Location: Northwest Ohio
Looks like Griatch and Moko have the same idea about a button to choose yay or nay for critique.


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Mon Aug 19, 2013 3:53 pm  (#43) 
Offline
GimpChat Member
User avatar

Joined: Nov 15, 2012
Posts: 949
Location: Mesa, AZ
I voted yes on the idea of a focused critique section. But with one caveat. You should have to explain what area of the image you're looking for feedback on. What this does is, it opens the door for people to give you opinions; it guides the critical eye in the direction you're looking for help with. And it means you're the first one to look at your own work with that evil eye. So it's fair when others join in on the 'hot-seating'.

I don't know what led to this discussion, as I too, was absent for a good long while from gimpchat (Sorry guys, real life bit me pretty hard for a while there.) I always try to be constructive when I see a perceived flaw in someone's work, but I also try to be respectful of the undoubted time and effort they poured into creating that piece to begin with. I expect the same from everyone else and here at gimpchat I've been receiving that. Along with a good amount of ego stroking. (Thanks y'all.) Anyone that got their panties in a wad over the type of critique they received here has some issues that we as a forum can't or shouldn't address to begin with.

I wouldn't mind having a brutal honesty section that those that only want to share their joy with the world can steer clear of. That's all K1te is trying to accomplish, I think. And I'll back it 100%.

_________________
Image

I now have a Tumblr, check it out!


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 10:35 am  (#44) 
Offline
GimpChat Founder
User avatar

Joined: May 22, 2008
Posts: 5244
Location: Gimpville
I agree that moderating opinions, even in a critique free section, is a bad idea and would most likely lead to problems.

I guess that leaves us with the options of having a separate section for the more focused critique or just making it easier for someone to request a more detailed critique by providing check box or dropdown in the Art section.

A compromise option might be just a note. There is a feature of this board that allows the admins to place messages/rules at the top of any forum. The message will appear when someone browses the forum or a thread in the forum. I've enabled that feature in the Art section to demonstrate how it works.

What do y'all think of that idea? I can change the text to whatever we decide, as well as style the text with BBcode.

_________________
"If Microsoft ever does applications for Linux it means I've won." - Linus Torvalds


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 11:10 am  (#45) 
Offline
GimpChat Member
User avatar

Joined: Aug 28, 2012
Posts: 3060
Location: Idk where I am.
Worded close to how it is, looks reasonable enough!

_________________
Image
Reality is a lovely place...But I wouldn't wanna live there.


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 12:00 pm  (#46) 
Offline
GimpChat Member
User avatar

Joined: Apr 08, 2010
Posts: 5420
Location: Northwest Ohio
I like that solution, however is there a way to word it so that people won't be afraid to just make opinion comments or simple critique if the poster doesn't specify critique or not?


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 12:55 pm  (#47) 
Offline
GimpChat Member
User avatar

Joined: Nov 15, 2012
Posts: 949
Location: Mesa, AZ
Looks fine for me, but then again I got a pretty thick skin. I think it's a step in the right direction though and I'm sure a little light nudging when it comes to comments, the way it's always been, will be fine. At least this way it puts the tools to open up strong critique in the artists hand and that's what I wanted to see.

_________________
Image

I now have a Tumblr, check it out!


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 1:04 pm  (#48) 
Offline
GimpChat Member
User avatar

Joined: Aug 30, 2012
Posts: 2174
I like the new banner at least it gives some kind of direction.

_________________
Image


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 1:42 pm  (#49) 
Offline
GimpChat Founder
User avatar

Joined: May 22, 2008
Posts: 5244
Location: Gimpville
2-ton wrote:
I like that solution, however is there a way to word it so that people won't be afraid to just make opinion comments or simple critique if the poster doesn't specify critique or not?

Perhaps the wording could say..

When Posting In This Section, You Can Optionally Specify Whether You Would Like A Focused Critique Of Your Work.

..or something like that.

_________________
"If Microsoft ever does applications for Linux it means I've won." - Linus Torvalds


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 1:47 pm  (#50) 
Offline
GimpChat Member

Joined: Aug 27, 2010
Posts: 491
Wouldn't it be easier for people to ask for what they want in their original post?


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 1:49 pm  (#51) 
Offline
GimpChat Founder
User avatar

Joined: May 22, 2008
Posts: 5244
Location: Gimpville
Mike wrote:
Wouldn't it be easier for people to ask for what they want in their original post?

Yes. The purpose of the banner would be to remind members to do that.

_________________
"If Microsoft ever does applications for Linux it means I've won." - Linus Torvalds


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 6:02 pm  (#52) 
Offline
GimpChat Member
User avatar

Joined: Apr 07, 2010
Posts: 14182
I think the banner idea was super. short and to the point.

_________________
Image


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 7:15 pm  (#53) 
Offline
GimpChat Founder
User avatar

Joined: May 22, 2008
Posts: 5244
Location: Gimpville
I think this is the best wording..

When Posting In This Section, Let Us Know If You Would Like A More Detailed & Focused Critique Of Your Work

_________________
"If Microsoft ever does applications for Linux it means I've won." - Linus Torvalds


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 9:03 pm  (#54) 
Offline
Global Moderator
User avatar

Joined: May 16, 2010
Posts: 16275
The banner should pretty much kill 2 birds with one stone. :)
1) Budding artists can get all the critique they want.
2) No one has an excuse to leave because someone critiqued their art.

_________________
Image


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 9:49 pm  (#55) 
Offline
GimpChat Member
User avatar

Joined: Apr 08, 2010
Posts: 5420
Location: Northwest Ohio
Perfect wording! I like the banner rather than a focused section as there are already enough boards to check out. In fact, I find my self sticking to the recent post section for the most part.


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 10:04 pm  (#56) 
Offline
Former Member
User avatar

Joined: Nov 17, 2010
Posts: 618
Location: Rockford, IL
IMO things are fine the way they are, but It'd be nice to see a focused critique section strictly for that purpose. Saves time putting that info in the article when designing work for clients.


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Thu Aug 22, 2013 3:29 pm  (#57) 
Offline
GimpChat Founder
User avatar

Joined: May 22, 2008
Posts: 5244
Location: Gimpville
So, it everyone OK with the banner or should we just dump it, or should we try something else?

This thread kinda died so I wasn't sure.

_________________
"If Microsoft ever does applications for Linux it means I've won." - Linus Torvalds


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Thu Aug 22, 2013 3:34 pm  (#58) 
Offline
GimpChat Member
User avatar

Joined: Apr 07, 2010
Posts: 14182
I love the banner ,lets stick with it.

_________________
Image


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Thu Aug 22, 2013 3:47 pm  (#59) 
Offline
GimpChat Member
User avatar

Joined: Nov 15, 2012
Posts: 949
Location: Mesa, AZ
Banner is good if it makes people happy.

_________________
Image

I now have a Tumblr, check it out!


Top
 Post subject: Re: Creating A Focused Critique Section
PostPosted: Thu Aug 22, 2013 5:17 pm  (#60) 
Offline
GimpChat Member
User avatar

Joined: Apr 27, 2010
Posts: 1510
Location: Sweden
For me this rather creates a situation where people who I know normally wants feedback forgets to explicitly say so in their post ... is that now because they don't want feedback for that particular piece or did they forget? Will offering an opinion in that thread now suddenly bring mods to bear? This will certainly lessen my inclination to offer spontaneous feedback. If I'm not allowed to offer an honest opinion (because it was not explicitly allowed or most likely forgotten to be allowed by the poster) then I'll rather avoid posting.

I would prefer the opposite wording ("let us know if you do NOT want feedback on your work"), since not censoring the response thread is (in my mind at least) the default position for anyone posting their work online. But whichever people feel comfortable with by all means.
.
Griatch

_________________


Top
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 70 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next

All times are UTC - 5 hours [ DST ]



* Login  



Powered by phpBB3 © phpBB Group